Naturally people have their preferences--however, I am being asked to potentially purchase and support IPB instead of VB. Even though my company uses VB already for three of its forums and I have had ZERO problems (great job VB!) I need to handle this with a bit of tact. I asked the individual to give me reasons why we should go IPB over VB, here they are. I call upon the masses to look this over and let me know if the reasons given are legit (ITHO). I realize I am posting on VB's site for a response to this and the response may be bias--I am sold on VB already... I just need a consensus response to these reasons:
Note on Sys req's. I got a trial version of IPB up, IPB req's Zend optimizer... VB does not.
Regards
Price:
* The full license of Vbulletin is $160.00
* The full license of Invision is $185.00
- Vbulletin is slightly cheaper
Minimum System Requirements:
* Vbulletin: PHP 4.06, MySQL 3.23.33
* Invision: PHP 4.06, MySQL 3.23.33
- No difference
Portal System:
* Vbulletin: Not included in base package; available as add-on "VBAdvanced²
* Invision: IPB Portal included in base package.
- Invision is superior in this respect.
Skinning and Languages:
* Vbulletin: Can be customized, uses templates and css, language packs
available.
* Invision: Integrated skin, css, language editor, uses template and css,
language packs available.
- Invision carries this field, with the editors integrated into the package.
Maintenance and Repair:
* Vbulletin: Integrated database manager for repair, backup and
optimization
* Invision: Integrated database manager for repair, backup and optimization
- No difference
Promotion:
* Vbulletin: No Tools
* Invision: Bulk Mailer, search engine spider controls
- Invision is superior
Posting:
* Vbulletin: Multiple attachments, Custom BBCodes, Multi-quote, BBCodes,
Emoticons, Bad-word filters
* Invision: Multiple attachments, Custom BBCodes, Multi-quote, BBCodes,
Emoticons, Bad-word filters
- No difference
Viewing Topics and Posts:
* Vbulletin - Linear, Threaded, Hybrid display views available.
* Invision - Outline, Standard & Linear+ topic views, User-selectable
pagination, Topic & post subscriptions
- Invision carries this category.
Installation:
* Vbulletin - Integrated installer, Supported RDBMS'
* Invision - Integrated installer, Supported RDBMS'
- No difference.
Users & Groups:
* Vbulletin - Permission system, based on user, usergroup or forums
* Invision - Permissions masks, Multi-user groups, Group promotion, Custom
profile fields
- Invision is slightly superior
Forum Control:
* Vbulletin: Basic
* Invision: Unlimited sub-forums, Independent forum skins, Redirect
forums, Trash-can forum, Password-protected forums.
- Invision has more of these features.
Moderation:
* Vbulletin: Topic multi-moderation, Global and forum moderators,
moderation queue.
* Invision: Topic multi-moderation, Inline moderation, Global and
forum moderators, Moderation queue.
- Invision has a big lead with inline moderation features.
Searching:
* Vbulletin: Easy and advanced search options.
* Invision: Full-text searching, Easy and advanced search options.
- Invision has the edge here with full text searching.
Note on Sys req's. I got a trial version of IPB up, IPB req's Zend optimizer... VB does not.
Regards
Price:
* The full license of Vbulletin is $160.00
* The full license of Invision is $185.00
- Vbulletin is slightly cheaper
Minimum System Requirements:
* Vbulletin: PHP 4.06, MySQL 3.23.33
* Invision: PHP 4.06, MySQL 3.23.33
- No difference
Portal System:
* Vbulletin: Not included in base package; available as add-on "VBAdvanced²
* Invision: IPB Portal included in base package.
- Invision is superior in this respect.
Skinning and Languages:
* Vbulletin: Can be customized, uses templates and css, language packs
available.
* Invision: Integrated skin, css, language editor, uses template and css,
language packs available.
- Invision carries this field, with the editors integrated into the package.
Maintenance and Repair:
* Vbulletin: Integrated database manager for repair, backup and
optimization
* Invision: Integrated database manager for repair, backup and optimization
- No difference
Promotion:
* Vbulletin: No Tools
* Invision: Bulk Mailer, search engine spider controls
- Invision is superior
Posting:
* Vbulletin: Multiple attachments, Custom BBCodes, Multi-quote, BBCodes,
Emoticons, Bad-word filters
* Invision: Multiple attachments, Custom BBCodes, Multi-quote, BBCodes,
Emoticons, Bad-word filters
- No difference
Viewing Topics and Posts:
* Vbulletin - Linear, Threaded, Hybrid display views available.
* Invision - Outline, Standard & Linear+ topic views, User-selectable
pagination, Topic & post subscriptions
- Invision carries this category.
Installation:
* Vbulletin - Integrated installer, Supported RDBMS'
* Invision - Integrated installer, Supported RDBMS'
- No difference.
Users & Groups:
* Vbulletin - Permission system, based on user, usergroup or forums
* Invision - Permissions masks, Multi-user groups, Group promotion, Custom
profile fields
- Invision is slightly superior
Forum Control:
* Vbulletin: Basic
* Invision: Unlimited sub-forums, Independent forum skins, Redirect
forums, Trash-can forum, Password-protected forums.
- Invision has more of these features.
Moderation:
* Vbulletin: Topic multi-moderation, Global and forum moderators,
moderation queue.
* Invision: Topic multi-moderation, Inline moderation, Global and
forum moderators, Moderation queue.
- Invision has a big lead with inline moderation features.
Searching:
* Vbulletin: Easy and advanced search options.
* Invision: Full-text searching, Easy and advanced search options.
- Invision has the edge here with full text searching.
Comment