PDA

View Full Version : Why does the user chooses his own password at registration????


bira
Sun 14th May '00, 7:29am
This is a major security problem.

Why on earth does it allow the user to choose his\her own password upon registration? This way, there is no substance to the e-mail check. A user can make up a ficticious e-mail address when registaring - what does he\she care: they already have a username and password.

I didn't realize this until now, and as far as I am concerned this is a HUGE problem.

I BEG you to to provide a hack to this PLEASE. Without this, I have absolutely zero way of knowing if a user had used a valid e-mail address.

This is really bad... :(


p.s.

And don't tell me the activation link solves that, because the syntax of the activation link is a joke -- once you've seen it you know how to type it in the address bar without waiting for the e-mail to arrive.

I'm so depressed by this... I've been excited about switching to vB all weekend and this is such a setback :(

[Edited by bira on 05-15-2000 at 02:38 AM]

John
Sun 14th May '00, 8:28am
Yes - I am aware that it is not the most secure way of doing it. I am working on a more secure way that requires a unique number to be passed through the URL.

John

bira
Sun 14th May '00, 8:31am
Originally posted by John
Yes - I am aware that it is not the most secure way of doing it. I am working on a more secure way that requires a unique number to be passed through the URL.

John

John,

Seeing as I will not make the switch to vB until that is done (although I already paid for it), can you please give me a timeframe of when this will be done?

Thank you,

Bira